All articles

Digital Marketing

SEO agency red flags: 12 warning signs to walk away from

The warning signs of a bad SEO agency: guarantees, secret methods, link packages, vague reports and contracts you can't leave, and what good looks like instead.

Genvora teamPublished 5 min read
Red warning flag on a beach

The biggest red flags in an SEO agency are guaranteed rankings, methods they won't explain, links they buy, reports with no business numbers in them, and contracts that lock you in before they've shown any results. Any one of these is a reason to slow down. Two or more, and you're usually better off walking away, however good the price looks.

Most of these come up in the first sales call or the first proposal, so you can spot them before you've spent anything. For each one below there's what it sounds like, why it matters, and what a good agency says instead.

The short version

  • Nobody can guarantee a ranking on Google. An agency that does is either guessing or planning something risky.
  • You should be able to understand what they'll change on your site and why.
  • Bought links and "link packages" can get your site demoted.
  • Reports should show the enquiries or sales that came from search, alongside rankings and traffic.
  • You should own your website, content and accounts, and be able to leave with a fair notice period.

Red flags in the sales conversation

1. "We guarantee page one"

Google says plainly that no one can guarantee a number one ranking. Nobody outside Google controls the results, and they change all the time. When an agency guarantees a position, it usually means a search nobody actually types, a ranking that won't last, or tactics that break Google's rules. A good agency talks about what it expects to happen and how it will measure it, not what it promises.

2. "We have a special relationship with Google"

No agency gets priority treatment in Google's organic results. Being a Google Partner relates to Google Ads, the paid side, and has nothing to do with where you rank for free. If an agency blurs the two, ask it to explain the difference. Its answer will tell you a lot.

3. It found you with a cold email

"I noticed your site isn't ranking for your main keywords" is one of the most common sales emails in the world, and Google specifically warns about unsolicited SEO offers. Some honest agencies do prospect by email, but the ones sending thousands of identical messages are rarely the ones you want working on your website.

4. They talk about keywords before they ask about your business

A good first call is mostly questions: what you sell, which services make the most money, where customers come from now, what a new customer is worth. An agency that jumps straight to a list of keywords and a monthly fee is selling a package, not a plan for your business.

Red flags in how they work

5. Secret methods

"Our process is proprietary" sounds impressive and tells you nothing. Real SEO work isn't secret: technical fixes, better pages, useful content, earning links and mentions. If an agency won't explain what it's doing to your website, assume you wouldn't approve if you knew.

6. Link packages

"50 high authority backlinks a month" is a link scheme, and Google's spam policies are clear that buying links to manipulate rankings can get a site demoted or removed. Good agencies earn links by giving other sites a reason to mention you: useful content, data, expert comment, local partnerships. It's slower and it lasts.

7. Hundreds of pages, quickly

Watch for proposals that promise large numbers of thin pages: one for every town in the county with the name swapped, or dozens of articles a month written to a template. Google treats mass-produced pages made mainly to rank as spam, and it can drag down the rest of your site with them.

8. They want ownership of your accounts

An agency needs access to your Search Console, analytics and website. It shouldn't own them. Accounts set up in the agency's name mean you lose your history and data when you leave. Ask for everything to be created in your name, with the agency added as a user.

Red flags in reporting

9. Rankings with no business numbers

A report full of green arrows for searches nobody buys from is easy to produce and worth very little. A useful report shows organic enquiries or sales, alongside traffic and rankings, and explains what was done and what happens next. Our guide to what an SEO report should include covers this in detail.

10. You can't tell what they did this month

If you read the monthly report and still couldn't say what work was done, ask. A good agency can list the changes it made, the pages it published or improved, and the problems it fixed. "Ongoing optimisation" is not a deliverable.

Red flags in the contract

11. A long term with no way out

Six to twelve months is common for SEO, because it takes time to work. That's fine if there's a clear goal for the first 90 days and a way to leave if it's missed. Twelve months with no exit and no measurable goal puts all the risk on you. Our guide to SEO contracts lists the clauses to check.

12. A price that seems too good

Cheap SEO has to cut corners somewhere: automated reports, links bought in bulk, content nobody checks, or one person juggling dozens of clients. Our article on what affects the cost of SEO explains what you're paying for when the price is fair.

What good looks like instead

Red flagWhat a good agency does
Guarantees a rankingExplains what it expects and how it will measure progress
Won't explain its methodsTells you what it will change on your site and why
Sells link packagesEarns mentions through content, data and real relationships
Reports rankings onlyReports enquiries and sales from search, plus the work done
Owns your accountsSets everything up in your name
Long contract, no goalAgrees a 90-day goal and a fair notice period

If you're comparing agencies now, our guide to choosing an SEO agency has the 12 questions to ask and a free scorecard for comparing the answers.

Frequently asked questions

Is it a bad sign if an SEO agency asks for a 12-month contract?

Not on its own. SEO often takes several months to show results, so longer terms are common. The warning sign is a long term with no measurable goal for the first 90 days and no fair way to leave.

What should I do if I think my current agency is using bad tactics?

Ask for a list of every link they've built and every change they've made to your site. Check Search Console for manual action messages. If you find paid links or spammy pages, stop the work and get a second opinion before anything else goes live.

Can a bad SEO agency harm my website?

Yes. Bought links, thin pages and hidden text can lead to your site being demoted or removed from Google's results. Recovering can take months, so check an agency's methods before you hire it.

Want to put us to the test?

Ask us anything on this list. Our SEO services team explains every change in plain English, sets up accounts in your name and puts a 90-day goal in every proposal. Book a call when you're ready.

3.2x
Organic sessions
−41%
Blended CAC

See it in practice · D2C / E-commerce

D2C brand 3.2x organic traffic in 6 months

Read the story ›

Curious how your own site scores?

Run our free website audit. Simple report, about 10 seconds, no sign-up.

Run free audit
All articles