The best way to choose an SEO agency is to ask specific questions about how they will grow your revenue, who will do the work, and how they will prove progress, then compare the answers in writing. Good agencies explain their plan in plain language, show relevant results, avoid guarantees, and agree a measurable goal for the first 90 days. Weak agencies talk about rankings, hide their methods, and ask for long contracts before showing any value.
Below are the 12 questions we would ask if we were hiring an SEO agency ourselves, what a good answer sounds like, and the warning signs to watch for. The advice applies whether you are in the US or the UK, and it lines up with Google’s own guidance on hiring an SEO.
The short version
- Decide what you want SEO to do for the business before you speak to anyone.
- Shortlist three agencies and put the same 12 questions to each of them.
- Score the answers side by side. The agency with a specific plan for your site and a measurable 90-day goal is usually the right one.
- Walk away from guaranteed rankings, secret methods and paid links.
How to choose an SEO agency, step by step
- 1Write down what you want SEO to do: the services you most want to sell, what a new customer is worth, and where your leads come from today. The next section explains why this matters.
- 2Make a shortlist of three. Ask businesses you trust who they use, look at who ranks for searches in your own industry, and read the case studies on agency websites. Three is enough to compare properly without losing weeks to sales calls.
- 3Check the basics before you book any calls. Are the case studies about businesses like yours? Do they explain their process in plain language? Is their own website fast and easy to use? An agency that can’t get its own site right is unlikely to fix yours.
- 4Ask every agency the same 12 questions (they’re below). Asking the same questions is what makes the answers comparable.
- 5Score each agency straight after the call while it’s fresh, using the scorecard further down or our free fillable PDF version.
- 6Agree one measurable goal for the first 90 days and review it together before committing to anything longer.
What to look for in an SEO agency
Good SEO agencies have a few habits in common, and you can usually spot them in the first conversation. They ask about your customers and margins before they mention keywords. They can tell you what they’d change on your site in plain English, and why. Their results come with business numbers attached, such as enquiries or revenue, not only ranking screenshots. They’re happy to say what they don’t do. And they’ll put a goal in writing.
Weak agencies tend to do the opposite: lead with rankings, keep their methods vague, and push for a long contract before they’ve shown you anything.
Before you start: know what you want SEO to do
Agencies give better proposals when you can say what success means. Before the first call, write down three things: the products or services you most want to sell, roughly what a new customer is worth to you, and where your current leads or sales come from. An agency that does not ask about these is planning to sell you rankings, not growth.
12 questions to ask an SEO agency
1. Can you show me results for businesses like mine?
Ask for two or three examples in your industry or market, with numbers: organic traffic, leads, or revenue before and after. A good agency also offers a reference call. Be cautious if every example is a screenshot of rankings with no business result attached.
2. What would you do in the first 90 days?
A strong answer is specific to your site: the technical problems they already noticed, the pages they would create or improve first, and why. A weak answer is a generic list of “keyword research, on-page optimisation, and link building” that could apply to anyone.
3. How will you measure success?
Look for measures tied to your business, such as organic enquiries, qualified leads, or revenue, alongside traffic and rankings. Ask them to commit to one measurable goal for the first 90 days.
4. Who will actually work on our account?
Ask for names, roles, and experience, and how many other accounts each person handles. The senior person on the sales call is not always the person doing the work.
5. How do you build links?
Good answers involve creating content or data worth citing, digital PR, expert commentary, and genuine partnerships. Walk away if they mention buying links, private blog networks, or link packages. Google’s guidance specifically warns against SEOs who talk about link schemes.
6. Do you follow Google’s guidelines?
The answer should be a clear yes, with an explanation of how. Tactics that break Google’s spam policies can lead to your site being demoted or removed from search results, and the clean-up is slow and expensive.
7. What will you need from us?
SEO almost always needs input from your team: access to the website and analytics, approval of content, expert knowledge for articles, and developer time for technical fixes. A good agency tells you this up front, so delays are not blamed on you later.
8. Can you make technical changes, or will our developer need to?
Many SEO problems need code changes. Find out whether the agency has developers who can make them, or whether you need to budget for your own web developer’s time.
9. How do you approach AI search?
Google AI Overviews, ChatGPT search, and Perplexity now answer many questions directly. A current agency should explain how they structure content to be quoted, use schema markup, and track whether your brand appears in AI answers.
10. How will we communicate, and how often will we see reports?
Look for a named contact, a regular written update, and a monthly report that explains what changed, what was learned, and what happens next. Google also suggests asking whether the agency will explain every change it makes to your site.
11. What does it cost, and what exactly is included?
Ask for a monthly list of deliverables or hours, and what costs extra, such as content beyond the plan, design, digital PR, or VAT in the UK. Our guide to what affects the cost of SEO in the UK explains what drives a quote, so you can judge whether one is reasonable.
12. What happens if we want to leave?
You should keep everything: content, accounts, data, and any tools set up in your name. Check the notice period and whether the agency will hand over its work in a usable form.
Red flags when hiring an SEO agency
- Guaranteed rankings. Google states that no one can guarantee a number one ranking. Promises of page one in 30 days are a warning sign, not a selling point.
- A “special relationship” with Google. No agency has priority access to Google’s rankings.
- Cold emails offering cheap SEO. Google specifically warns about unsolicited SEO offers.
- Secret methods. If an agency will not explain what it is doing to your website, assume you would not approve of it.
- Requests for full admin access to everything on day one. An audit needs read access to Search Console and analytics, not ownership of your accounts.
- Ranking reports with no business metrics. Rankings for searches nobody buys from are easy to deliver and worth very little.
- Long contracts with no exit. Six to twelve month terms are common, but there should be a clear 90-day goal and a way out if it is missed.
A simple scorecard for comparing agencies
Score each agency from 1 to 5 on these points after the pitch, and compare the totals alongside price:
| Criteria | What a 5 looks like |
|---|---|
| Understanding of your business | Asked about customers, margins, and sales process before proposing anything |
| Specific plan | Named the pages, problems, and opportunities on your site |
| Relevant proof | Results in your industry or market, with a reference you can call |
| People | You met the people who will do the work |
| Measurement | Agreed a 90-day goal tied to leads or revenue |
| Methods | Clear, guideline-friendly approach to content and links |
| Contract terms | Clear deliverables, fair notice period, you own everything |
There’s also a fillable PDF version. It has columns for three agencies, the 12 questions with room for notes, and the red flags to tick off as you go. Or copy the questions below into your own notes for the call.
12 questions to ask an SEO agency
12 QUESTIONS TO ASK AN SEO AGENCY Agency: Date of call: 1. Can you show me results for businesses like mine? 2. What would you do in the first 90 days? 3. How will you measure success? 4. Who will actually work on our account? 5. How do you build links? 6. Do you follow Google's guidelines? 7. What will you need from us? 8. Can you make technical changes, or will our developer need to? 9. How do you approach AI search? 10. How will we communicate, and how often will we see reports? 11. What does it cost, and what exactly is included? 12. What happens if we want to leave? RED FLAGS SPOTTED [ ] Guaranteed rankings [ ] Claims a special relationship with Google [ ] Won't explain their methods [ ] Buys links or sells link packages [ ] Wants full admin access to everything on day one [ ] Reports rankings only, no business numbers [ ] Long contract with no 90-day goal or way out
Choosing a specialist SEO agency
The 12 questions work for any agency. If you need a particular kind of SEO, add a couple of questions of your own.
Technical SEO agency
Worth it for large sites, custom-built platforms, or sites that lost traffic after a move or redesign. Ask how they deal with crawling, indexing, page speed and redirects, and whether they make the code changes themselves or hand your developer a list. Our technical SEO page shows what that work usually covers, and our guide to redesigning without losing rankings explains the redirect side.
Local SEO agency
If your customers come from one area, ask how they’ll improve your Google Business Profile, bring in more reviews and build pages for the places you serve. The local SEO checklist gives you a good idea of what they should be talking about.
SEO agency for a WordPress site
Ask whether they’ll work with your current theme and plugins or want to replace them, which SEO plugin they prefer, and who fixes things when a plugin update breaks something. Plenty of SEO problems on WordPress sites come from too many plugins, so an agency that wants to add five more is worth questioning.
SEO agency for a SaaS or B2B company
Look for an agency that talks about pipeline, trials and demos rather than traffic, and knows how to write for buyers who research for weeks before they get in touch. Our article on SEO for SaaS companies covers what changes.
Agency, freelancer or in-house?
An agency isn’t the only option. Here’s how the three usually compare.
| Option | Usually suits | Watch out for |
|---|---|---|
| SEO agency | Businesses that need several skills at once: technical fixes, content and links | Who actually does the work, and how long the contract runs |
| Freelancer | A clear, narrow job, such as a technical audit or a set of articles | Cover when they’re ill or on holiday, and a narrower range of skills |
| In-house hire | Large sites with a steady, high volume of SEO work | Hiring time, plus the tools and training one person needs |
Our comparison of a marketing agency vs an in-house team goes into this in more depth.
Contract terms to check before you sign
- 1Term and notice. How long is the minimum term, and what notice is needed after it?
- 2Scope. Are the monthly deliverables listed, or only described as “SEO activity”?
- 3Ownership. Do you own all content, data, and accounts created during the engagement?
- 4Access. Will the agency use accounts in your name, so you keep history if you leave?
- 5Price changes. Can the fee rise during the term, and with how much notice?
- 6Data protection. In the UK, check the agency will sign a data processing agreement under UK GDPR if it handles customer data.
Frequently asked questions
Which SEO agency should I hire?
The one that can explain in plain English what it would change on your site in the first 90 days and why, shows results for businesses like yours, introduces the people who will do the work, and puts a measurable goal in writing. Put the same 12 questions to three agencies and compare the answers side by side. Price only becomes a fair comparison once the plans are.
How do I find SEO agencies to shortlist?
Ask businesses you trust who they use, look at who ranks for searches in your own industry, and read the case studies on agency websites. Directories and review sites are useful for finding names, but the questions above are what tell you whether an agency is any good.
How long does it take an SEO agency to get results?
Technical fixes can show up within weeks, but new content and links take longer. Google’s own guidance says it often takes four months to a year to see the benefit of SEO changes. That’s why the 90-day goal should include progress you can measure early, such as problems fixed, pages published and more impressions in Search Console, as well as leads.
Can an SEO agency guarantee first-page rankings?
No. Google says nobody can guarantee a number one ranking, because nobody outside Google controls its results. Treat a guarantee as a reason to walk away.
Should I hire an SEO agency near me?
It isn’t necessary. What matters is whether they understand your market and customers, and most SEO work happens remotely anyway. An agency in another city, or another country, can do excellent work if they’ve done it for businesses like yours. If you serve a local area, check they know local SEO specifically.
What should an SEO agency report each month?
What they did, what changed and what happens next, in plain language. The numbers should include organic enquiries or sales, not only traffic and rankings.
How long should an SEO contract be?
Six to twelve months is common because SEO takes time to work. Whatever the length, make sure there’s a clear goal for the first 90 days, a fair notice period, and that you keep all the work if you leave.
Want to put us through the 12 questions?
Choose the agency that understands your business, has a specific plan for your site, introduces the people who will do the work and agrees a measurable 90-day goal. Price matters, but a slightly more expensive agency with a clear plan usually costs far less than a year of work that doesn’t move your sales.
If you’d like to put us through these questions, book a call with our SEO services team. We work with businesses in the US and UK, and every proposal includes a written 90-day goal.
See it in practice · D2C / E-commerce
D2C brand 3.2x organic traffic in 6 months
Curious how your own site scores?
Run our free website audit. Simple report, about 10 seconds, no sign-up.



