Part of our guide: Website redesign: the complete guide for small businesses ›
The biggest worry with a new website is usually this one: what if we lose our Google rankings? It's a fair worry. Rankings can drop after a redesign, sometimes badly. But it is rarely bad luck. It nearly always comes down to a handful of avoidable mistakes, made in the rush to launch.
The plan below is built to avoid them. It's part of our complete guide to website redesign, and it pairs with the more detailed redesign checklist.
The short version
- List every page and note which ones bring visitors, links or enquiries.
- Keep page addresses where you can; redirect every one that changes to its closest match.
- Carry over the titles, headings and content that already rank.
- After launch, check Search Console daily for the first week and fix problems straight away.
Why rankings drop after a redesign
Most post-launch drops come down to one of these:
- Page addresses changed and the old ones lead to "page not found".
- Content that ranked was cut, merged or rewritten until it no longer answered the search.
- Pages lost their internal links, so Google and visitors struggle to find them.
- The staging site's "don't index this" setting was left on after launch.
- The new site is slower or harder to use on phones than the old one.
Each of these is preventable, and each of the steps below exists to stop one of them.
Step 1: make a list of every page
Before anything changes, build a spreadsheet of every page on the current site. You can get the addresses from a site crawler, your sitemap, or the Pages report in Google Search Console. Then add, for each page, how many clicks it gets from Google (Search Console's Performance report shows this) and whether other websites link to it. The pages with clicks or links are the ones that matter most.
Step 2: decide what happens to each page
| Decision | When | What to do |
|---|---|---|
| Keep | The page still makes sense on the new site | Keep the same address if you can, and improve the content |
| Merge | Two or more pages cover the same thing | Combine them into one strong page and redirect the others to it |
| Retire | The page is out of date and has no clicks or links | Remove it and redirect the address to the most relevant page |
Be careful with retiring pages that get clicks. If a page brings people in, it is usually better to update it than to remove it.
Step 3: build the redirect map
Add a column to your spreadsheet: the new address for every old one. Each old address that changes gets a 301 redirect to its closest match on the new site. A few rules make a big difference:
- Redirect to the most relevant page, not the homepage. Google treats mass redirects to the homepage much like a missing page.
- Avoid chains, where one redirect points to another. Point each old address straight to its final destination.
- Include the versions people forget: with and without www, old PDF links, and old blog addresses.
Step 4: keep what Google relies on
For every page that ranks, carry over the things Google has learned to trust: the page title, the main heading, the content that answers the search, and the meta description. Improve them by all means, but don't replace a page that ranks for "boiler repair Leeds" with a vague one called "Our solutions". Keep internal links pointing at your important pages too, so they don't end up orphaned.
Step 5: launch-day checks
- 1Remove any "noindex" setting carried over from the staging site, and check robots.txt isn't blocking Google.
- 2Test a sample of old addresses and confirm each one lands on the right new page.
- 3Check that every page has its title and meta description.
- 4Submit the new sitemap in Google Search Console.
- 5Test forms, phone links and analytics tracking.
Step 6: watch the first month
For the first week, check Search Console every day. Look at the Pages report for addresses Google can't find (404 errors) or can't index, and at the Performance report for any sudden drop in clicks. After that, weekly is enough. A small wobble while Google re-reads the site is normal. A steady slide on important pages usually means a redirect is missing or content was lost, so go back to your spreadsheet.
If you're changing domain name too
Moving to a new domain at the same time adds risk, so do it only if you need to. If you do, redirect every page from the old domain to its match on the new one, keep the old domain registered and redirecting for good, and use the Change of Address tool in Google Search Console to tell Google about the move.
Frequently asked questions
How long does it take rankings to recover after a redesign?
If the redirects and content were handled well, most sites see little or no drop, and any wobble settles within a few weeks. If rankings keep falling after a month, something is usually missing and needs investigating rather than waiting.
Do 301 redirects lose ranking power?
Google has said that 301 redirects don't cause a loss of ranking signals. The bigger risk is redirecting to the wrong page, or not redirecting at all.
How long should I keep redirects in place?
Keep them for as long as you can, ideally permanently. Old links on other websites and in people's bookmarks keep working for years.
Want a second pair of eyes?
Our technical SEO team can run this whole process for you. If you're planning a redesign, or a recent launch has cost you traffic, book a call and we'll look at it with you.
See it in practice · FinTech
FinTech KYC review cut from 5 days to 4 hours
Curious how your own site scores?
Run our free website audit. Simple report, about 10 seconds, no sign-up.



