All articles

Accounting & Finance

Cash vs accrual accounting: what's the difference and which should you use?

Cash vs accrual accounting explained for small businesses in the US and UK: how each records income and costs, worked examples, what the tax rules allow, and which gives a truer picture.

Genvora teamPublished 5 min read
Calculator and pen resting on a red notebook

Part of our guide: Bookkeeping basics for small businesses: a complete beginner's guide ›

There are two main ways to decide when a sale or a cost goes into your books. Cash accounting records them when money actually moves. Accrual accounting records them when they're earned or incurred, whether or not anyone has paid yet. The choice changes what your profit looks like month to month, how much tax you pay in a given year, and how useful your reports are.

The short version

  • Cash accounting: income counts when you're paid, and costs count when you pay.
  • Accrual accounting: income counts when you've earned it (usually when you invoice), and costs count when you've incurred them.
  • Cash is simpler and matches your bank balance. Accrual gives a truer picture of profit, especially if customers pay on credit.
  • In the UK, sole traders now use the cash basis by default; limited companies must use accrual accounts.
  • In the US, most small businesses can choose cash, but must be consistent and may need IRS permission to change.

How each method works

EventCash accountingAccrual accounting
You send a $5,000 invoice in MarchNothing recorded$5,000 income in March
The customer pays in May$5,000 income in MayNothing new (the invoice is marked paid)
You receive a supplier bill in MarchNothing recordedExpense in March
You pay the bill in AprilExpense in AprilNothing new
You pay a year's insurance upfront in JanuaryFull cost in JanuarySpread over 12 months

A worked example

A consultancy invoices 20,000 of work in December, but the client pays in January. December's costs, 8,000, were paid in December.

  • Under cash accounting, December shows income of 0 and costs of 8,000: an 8,000 loss. January shows a 20,000 gain.
  • Under accrual accounting, December shows income of 20,000 and costs of 8,000: a 12,000 profit, which is what the business really made that month.

If December is the end of the tax year, that timing difference also moves 20,000 of taxable income from one year to the next.

Pros and cons

CashAccrual
SimplicityVery simple; follows your bankMore work; tracks invoices, bills and adjustments
Picture of profitCan be misleading month to monthMatches income with the costs of earning it
Cash awarenessShows cash clearlyProfit and cash can differ, so you need a cash flow report too
Tax timingYou don't pay tax on income you haven't receivedYou can owe tax on invoices that haven't been paid yet
Good forSmall, simple businesses paid quicklyBusinesses with credit terms, stock, staff or growth plans

What the UK rules say

Since April 2024, the cash basis has been the default for sole traders and partnerships of individuals, with no turnover limit. You can opt out and use traditional accruals accounting instead, which can suit businesses with stock, big upfront costs, or a need to claim certain losses. Limited companies must prepare accrual accounts under UK accounting standards.

VAT has its own, separate choice: the VAT cash accounting scheme changes when VAT is paid, regardless of how you do your income tax accounts.

What the US rules say

Most small businesses can use the cash method for tax, as long as their average annual gross receipts are below an inflation-adjusted limit of around 30 million dollars. Businesses above that, and some others such as certain corporations and tax shelters, must use accrual. You choose your method on your first tax return, and changing later usually requires filing Form 3115 with the IRS.

Many US businesses use cash for tax but keep accrual-based management reports, because they give a better view of performance. Good software can produce both.

The adjustments accrual accounting adds

Accrual books need a few month-end adjustments that cash books don't. They sound technical but each one answers a simple question:

  • Accruals: have we had a service this month that hasn't been billed yet, such as electricity? Record an estimate so this month carries its cost.
  • Prepayments: have we paid upfront for something that covers several months, such as annual insurance? Spread the cost over the months it covers.
  • Deferred income: has a customer paid in advance for work we haven't done yet? Hold it back and count it as income when the work is delivered.
  • Depreciation: have we bought equipment that lasts years? Spread its cost over its useful life in the accounts.

Software can automate most of these with recurring entries. Done consistently, they're what make month-by-month profit figures reliable.

Which should you use?

  • Choose cash if you're small, paid at the time of sale or quickly after, and want the simplest possible books.
  • Choose accrual if customers pay on 30-day terms or longer, you hold stock, you have large prepaid costs, or you want reliable monthly profit figures.
  • Consider accrual if you plan to raise investment, borrow, or sell the business, as lenders and buyers expect accrual accounts.

How the method affects your decisions

The method isn't only about tax. Under cash accounting, a month where a big client pays three invoices at once looks brilliant, and the following month looks poor, even if the work was steady. Owners who read cash reports as profit can end up hiring after a lucky month or cutting back after a slow one. Accrual reports smooth that out by showing the work done in each month, which is why most growing businesses move to accrual reporting even if they keep cash for tax.

A middle ground

Some businesses use cash accounting for tax but track unpaid invoices and bills closely in their software. That gives most of the insight of accrual reporting, with cash-basis tax timing. A monthly look at aged receivables, meaning who owes you what and for how long, is the key report either way. Our month-end close checklist includes it.

Frequently asked questions

Can I switch from cash to accrual?

Yes, but there are transition rules so income isn't taxed twice or missed. In the UK, you can change from one tax year to the next. In the US, you usually need to file Form 3115. Plan the switch with your accountant.

Does accrual accounting mean paying tax on money I don't have?

It can, if you invoice before year end and the customer pays after. Bad debt relief applies if a customer never pays.

Which method do banks and investors prefer?

Usually accrual, because it shows what the business earned and owes, not just what cash moved in a period.

Is the cash basis the same as VAT cash accounting?

No. In the UK, the cash basis is for working out profit for income tax. VAT cash accounting is a separate VAT scheme.

Want help choosing the right method?

Our outsourced bookkeeping and business tax services teams set up your books on the method that fits, and produce the reports you need either way. See our bookkeeping basics, or book a call.

14d → 5d
Month-end close
12 → 1
Systems

See it in practice · Healthcare

Healthcare practice scaled bookkeeping across 12 locations

Read the story ›

Curious how your own site scores?

Run our free website audit. Simple report, about 10 seconds, no sign-up.

Run free audit
All articles