Part of our guide: Bookkeeping basics for small businesses: a complete beginner's guide ›
For most US small businesses, QuickBooks Online is the safer default, mainly because most American accountants and CPAs already use it and it has payroll built in. Xero is a strong alternative if you want unlimited users on every plan, a cleaner interface, or you also have a business in the UK, Australia or New Zealand where Xero is more common. Both handle bank feeds, invoicing, bills and reports well.
The best choice often comes down to who'll be working in the books with you. If your accountant or bookkeeper prefers one, that usually settles it.
The short version
- QuickBooks Online: the most familiar system for US accountants, with payroll and 1099 tools built in.
- Xero: unlimited users on every plan, a tidy interface, and popular with businesses that also trade in the UK.
- Both connect to US banks, Stripe, Shopify, Square and hundreds of other apps.
- Check how each handles sales tax for the states you sell in.
- Pick based on your accountant, your payroll needs and how many people need access.
Side-by-side comparison
| QuickBooks Online | Xero | |
|---|---|---|
| Used by US accountants | Very widely; the default for many CPA firms | Less common in the US, very common in the UK and Australia |
| Users | Limited by plan | Unlimited on every plan |
| Payroll | QuickBooks Payroll built in | Through partner apps such as Gusto |
| 1099 contractors | Built-in 1099 tracking and filing | Tracking built in; filing usually through a partner |
| Sales tax | Automated sales tax built in | Sales tax tracking built in; check which plans include automated rates |
| Inventory | Basic inventory on higher plans | Basic tracked inventory; apps for anything more |
| Multi-currency | On higher plans | On higher plans |
| Interface | Busy but familiar | Clean and simple |
Features and plan limits change often, so check the current plans on each provider's site before you decide.
Choose QuickBooks Online if
- Your CPA or bookkeeper already uses it, which most in the US do.
- You want payroll in the same system as your books.
- You pay a lot of contractors and want 1099s handled in the same place.
- You'd like the widest choice of US bookkeepers who can step in if needed.
Choose Xero if
- Several people need access and you don't want to pay per user.
- You also run a business in the UK or another market where Xero is common, and want one system.
- You prefer a simpler screen and are happy using an app such as Gusto for payroll.
- Your accountant prefers Xero.
What matters more than the software
Either system works well if the basics are right: a separate business bank account, a sensible chart of accounts, bank feeds reconciled every month and receipts attached as you go. Most messy books come from skipping those steps, not from choosing the wrong software. Our bookkeeping basics guide covers the routine.
Switching from one to the other
You can move between them, usually at the start of a year or quarter. Migration tools carry over contacts, open invoices and balances, but not always full transaction history, so keep read access to the old system for at least your record-keeping period. Plan the switch with your accountant so year-end isn't affected.
Frequently asked questions
Do CPAs prefer QuickBooks or Xero?
In the US, most CPAs and bookkeepers use QuickBooks Online, though many also support Xero. Ask yours before you choose.
Can Xero run US payroll?
Not on its own. US businesses on Xero usually run payroll through a partner such as Gusto, which syncs payroll entries back into Xero.
Is QuickBooks Online the same as QuickBooks Desktop?
No. QuickBooks Online is the cloud version and is what most small businesses use now. Intuit has been moving customers away from the desktop products.
Want your books set up properly?
Our bookkeeping team works in both QuickBooks Online and Xero, sets up your accounts, bank feeds and sales tax, and closes the books every month. Stuck between the two? Book a call and we'll tell you which one we'd pick for your business, and why.
See it in practice · Healthcare
Healthcare practice scaled bookkeeping across 12 locations
Curious how your own site scores?
Run our free website audit. Simple report, about 10 seconds, no sign-up.



