Part of our guide: Website redesign: the complete guide for small businesses ›
Hardly anyone decides to redesign their website on a quiet Tuesday. It gets put off until something forces the question: a customer says the site looks dated, a competitor launches something sharp, or someone discovers the contact form hasn't sent an email in six weeks. Then the decision gets made in a hurry.
It is easier to decide calmly with a list in front of you. Here are the signs we look for. One on its own is usually something you can fix. Three or four at once, and a redesign starts to earn its keep. If you get there, our complete guide to website redesign covers what to do next.
The short version
- A single problem, like a slow page or a broken form, is usually a fix, not a redesign.
- Several problems at once, especially on phones, usually mean the structure itself is the issue.
- Check the facts before deciding: a two-minute audit and speed test will tell you more than a gut feeling.
It's hard to use on a phone
Open your site on your own phone and try to do the one thing you most want visitors to do, whether that's booking, calling or sending an enquiry. If you have to pinch, zoom, scroll sideways or hunt for the button, so does everyone else. On many small business sites, phones now account for most visits, and Google looks at the mobile version of a site when it decides rankings.
It takes ages to load
If the main content takes more than a few seconds to appear on a phone, some visitors leave before they see it. Google also measures speed through its Core Web Vitals. Run our website speed test to see where you stand. A slow site can sometimes be fixed by compressing images and removing old plugins; if the slowness comes from how the whole site is built, that's harder.
Visitors arrive but don't get in touch
This is the one that costs money quietly. Traffic in Google Analytics looks steady, but enquiries have drifted down. Often the site makes people work too hard: the services are vague, there is no obvious next step, or the contact form asks for too much. Some of that is copy, but when it runs through every page, it's usually a sign the site was never planned around what customers want to do.
It no longer describes your business
You've added services, dropped others, moved premises or grown the team, and the website still reflects the business you were three years ago. Patching individual pages helps for a while, but eventually the menu, the homepage and the story all need rethinking together.
Nobody can update it
If changing a sentence means emailing a developer and waiting a week, the site stops being updated. News goes stale, offers stay up after they've ended, and staff stop sending people to it. A modern site should let you change text and photos yourself in minutes.
Browsers call it "Not secure"
If visitors see a "Not secure" label next to your address, your site isn't using HTTPS. That alone is quick to fix with a security certificate from your host. But if it hasn't been done, it is worth asking what else has been left behind, because sites without HTTPS are often running old software too.
Google can't make sense of it
Missing page titles, the same meta description on every page, one long page trying to cover every service. These make it hard for Google to know which page to show for which search. Our free website audit checks the basics in about ten seconds.
It's built on something nobody supports any more
Old themes, plugins that haven't been updated in years, a site builder that has closed down or a developer nobody can reach. None of these are visible to visitors until something breaks, but they are real security and reliability risks.
It doesn't do what customers now expect
Customers increasingly expect to book online, pay online, or at least tap a phone number to call. If your competitors offer that and you don't, people notice. Adding features to an old site is sometimes possible, sometimes not, and that answer often decides the redesign question on its own.
You avoid sending people to it
This might be the most honest test of all. If you hesitate before putting your web address on a proposal, or you tell new contacts to look you up somewhere else instead, you already know the answer.
When it isn't a redesign problem
Some problems look like they need a new website but don't:
- One slow page, usually because of a huge image or video.
- A broken form or an out-of-date phone number.
- Low traffic from Google on an otherwise good site, which is usually an SEO job.
- A dated look on a site that works well. A refresh of colours, fonts and photos may be enough.
If you're not sure which camp you're in, our article on refresh, redesign or rebuild walks through the difference.
Frequently asked questions
How old is too old for a website?
Age matters less than how it works. A five-year-old site that is fast, easy to update and brings in enquiries doesn't need replacing. A two-year-old site that does none of those things might.
Will a redesign fix low Google traffic?
Not on its own. A redesign can remove technical problems that hold rankings back, but traffic grows from useful content and a site Google can understand. A badly planned redesign can even lose traffic, which is why protecting your rankings is a step of its own.
What to do next
Start with the facts: run the free website audit and the speed test. If several signs above ring true, read the complete redesign guide, or book a call and we'll give you an honest view of whether a redesign is worth it.
See it in practice · FinTech
FinTech KYC review cut from 5 days to 4 hours
Curious how your own site scores?
Run our free website audit. Simple report, about 10 seconds, no sign-up.



