All articles

Website Development

Refresh, redesign or rebuild: which does your website need?

Three very different projects get called a website redesign. How to tell which one you need, what each involves, and the mistake that wastes the most time.

Genvora teamPublished 3 min read
Colour swatch cards and pens on a designer's desk

Part of our guide: Website redesign: the complete guide for small businesses ›

"We need a new website" can mean three quite different things. Sometimes it means the site looks tired. Sometimes it means it no longer works for the business. Sometimes it means the system underneath has had its day. They are different sizes of project, with different risks, and mixing them up is how a two-week job turns into a four-month one.

The quickest way to tell them apart is to ask what is actually wrong. For the whole process from start to launch, see our complete guide to website redesign.

The short version

  • A refresh changes how the site looks. Pages and addresses stay put.
  • A redesign changes how the site works: structure, content and design.
  • A rebuild changes what the site is built on, usually to add features or fix a failing platform.

Refresh: same site, new clothes

A refresh updates the look without touching the structure. New colours and fonts, better photos, tidier spacing, some rewritten headlines. Page addresses stay the same, so there is very little risk to your Google rankings.

It fits when the site works well (people find what they need and get in touch) but looks dated next to competitors. It's also a sensible first step if a full redesign isn't possible this year.

Redesign: rethinking how the site works

A redesign starts from the question "what should this website do?" rather than "how should it look?". The page structure is planned again, content is rewritten, pages are merged or added, and the design follows from that. It usually stays on the same platform, or a similar one.

It fits when the site no longer matches the business, visitors don't convert, or the structure has grown messy after years of additions. Because page addresses often change, protecting your rankings is part of the job. Our guide to redesigning without losing rankings explains how.

Rebuild: new foundations

A rebuild replaces the platform and the code underneath, usually alongside a redesign. It's the right call when the current system is slow, insecure, no longer supported, or simply can't do what the business needs, such as online booking, payments or a connection to your other systems.

It is the biggest of the three and carries the most risk, so it needs the most planning: content moves, redirects, integrations and testing.

Side by side

RefreshRedesignRebuild
What changesLook and feelStructure, content and designPlatform, code and usually everything above
Page addressesStay the sameSome changeOften change
Risk to Google rankingsLowMedium, manageable with redirectsHigher, needs careful planning
Typical lengthA few weeksAround 6 to 12 weeks for a small businessLonger, depending on features

Questions that usually decide it

  • Do visitors find what they need and get in touch? If yes, a refresh may be enough.
  • Has the business changed since the site was planned? If yes, you probably need a redesign.
  • Can your current platform do what you need for the next few years? If not, it's a rebuild.
  • Can you update it yourself? If the answer is no and the platform is the reason, that points to a rebuild too.

The mistake that wastes the most time

Rebuilding to fix a content problem. If visitors leave because the pages don't answer their questions, a new platform won't help; the same words on new technology get the same result. It works the other way too: a beautiful refresh won't save a site whose platform is failing. Diagnose first. Our free website audit and speed test are a quick place to start.

Frequently asked questions

Is a refresh worth doing if we'll redesign next year?

Sometimes. If the site is losing you business now, a light refresh can help in the meantime. Just keep it small, so the money and effort go into the bigger project.

Can we rebuild without changing how the site looks?

Yes. Moving to a better platform while keeping the design is common when the look works but the system behind it doesn't. Visitors may not notice anything apart from the site getting faster.

Not sure which you need?

Tell us what's frustrating you about your current site and we'll tell you honestly which of the three fits. See our website design service, or book a call.

5d → 4h
Review time
−93%
Time to decision

See it in practice · FinTech

FinTech KYC review cut from 5 days to 4 hours

Read the story ›

Curious how your own site scores?

Run our free website audit. Simple report, about 10 seconds, no sign-up.

Run free audit
All articles