Part of our guide: US small business tax: the complete guide for owners and freelancers ›
"Should I be an LLC or an S corp?" is one of the most common questions US business owners ask, and it's slightly the wrong question. An LLC is a type of legal entity you form with your state. An S corporation is a tax status you choose with the IRS. Many small businesses are both: an LLC that has elected to be taxed as an S corp. The real question is whether that election would save you money.
The short version
- An LLC protects your personal assets and, by default, is taxed like a sole proprietorship or partnership.
- An S corp election changes how profit is taxed. You pay yourself a reasonable salary through payroll, and take the rest as distributions that aren't subject to self-employment tax.
- The saving is mainly on the 15.3% self-employment tax, so it grows with profit.
- It also adds costs: payroll, a separate business tax return, and sometimes state fees.
- Many advisers start looking at an S corp once net profit is reliably above roughly $50,000 to $80,000 a year, but the right point depends on your numbers and state.
What an LLC is
A limited liability company is created under state law. Its main job is legal: it separates the business from you, so business debts and lawsuits generally can't reach your personal assets, as long as you keep the two properly apart.
For tax, the IRS ignores a single-member LLC by default. You report the profit on Schedule C of your personal return and pay income tax plus self-employment tax on all of it, exactly like a sole proprietor. A multi-member LLC is taxed as a partnership by default.
What an S corp is
An S corporation is a federal tax election, made on Form 2553. Both corporations and LLCs can make it, as long as they meet the rules: no more than 100 shareholders, all US citizens or residents (with some exceptions for trusts and estates), and one class of stock.
An S corp doesn't pay federal income tax itself. Profit passes through to the owners' personal returns. The difference is in how owners who work in the business are paid.
How the S corp saves tax
As an S corp owner who works in the business, you must pay yourself a reasonable salary through payroll. That salary carries Social Security and Medicare taxes, split between you and the company. Any remaining profit can be paid out as distributions, which are subject to income tax but not to self-employment or payroll tax.
An illustration
Say your business makes $120,000 of net profit. Figures are rounded and ignore state taxes and the QBI deduction.
| Default LLC | LLC taxed as S corp | |
|---|---|---|
| How the owner is paid | All profit is self-employment income | $60,000 salary + $60,000 distributions |
| Social Security and Medicare | About $17,000 (15.3% of 92.35% of profit) | About $9,200 (15.3% of the $60,000 salary) |
| Extra costs | None | Payroll service, S corp tax return, possible state fees |
| Approximate difference | About $7,800 less in employment taxes, before extra costs |
Income tax is broadly similar either way, as all the profit is still taxed on your personal return. The saving comes from the part of profit that isn't salary.
The reasonable salary rule
The IRS expects S corp owners to pay themselves a salary that's reasonable for the work they do: roughly what you'd have to pay someone else to do your job. Paying yourself a tiny salary and taking everything as distributions is a well-known audit trigger, and the IRS can reclassify distributions as wages, with back taxes and penalties.
Useful evidence for a reasonable salary includes industry salary surveys, job postings for similar roles in your area, and what you'd pay a manager to run the business. Keep a note of how you decided.
The costs and extra work
- Running payroll for yourself, including quarterly payroll returns and a year-end W-2.
- Filing a separate S corp return (Form 1120-S) by March 15, plus a K-1 for each shareholder.
- State costs: some states charge S corp or franchise taxes, and a few don't recognize the election at all.
- More careful bookkeeping, keeping salary, distributions and expenses clearly separate.
- Health insurance and retirement contributions work differently for S corp owners.
If the saving from the illustration above is $7,800 and the extra costs are $2,000 to $3,000 a year, the election makes sense. At $40,000 of profit, the saving may barely cover the costs.
When an S corp may not make sense
- Your profit is low or very uneven from year to year.
- You want to reinvest most of the profit in the business rather than take it out.
- You plan to bring in investors or offer different share classes, which S corps don't allow.
- You operate in a state where S corp status brings extra taxes that outweigh the federal saving.
A quick way to estimate your own saving
- 1Take your expected net profit for the year.
- 2Decide on a reasonable salary for the work you do.
- 3Multiply the profit above that salary by about 14% to estimate the self-employment tax you'd save.
- 4Subtract your extra yearly costs: payroll, the S corp return and any state fees.
- 5If what's left is small, or your profit is uncertain, wait a year and look again.
How and when to elect
To take effect for the current tax year, Form 2553 generally has to be filed no later than two months and 15 days after the start of that year, so by March 15 for a calendar-year business. Late elections are sometimes accepted with reasonable cause. Elections can also start from a future year.
Official sources
Frequently asked questions
Is an S corp better than an LLC?
They aren't alternatives in the way people think. You can keep your LLC and elect S corp taxation. Whether that's better depends on your profit, state and plans.
Can a single-member LLC be an S corp?
Yes. A single-member LLC can elect S corp taxation as long as it meets the eligibility rules.
Does an S corp avoid income tax?
No. All the profit is still taxed on the owners' personal returns. The saving is on self-employment or payroll taxes on the distribution part.
Can I go back to being a regular LLC?
Yes, by revoking the election, but you generally can't re-elect S corp status for five years afterwards, so it's worth getting the decision right.
Want to know if an S corp would save you money?
Our business tax services team models both options on your real numbers, including state costs, and handles the election, payroll and returns. See our US small business tax guide, or book a call.
See it in practice · Healthcare
Healthcare practice scaled bookkeeping across 12 locations
Curious how your own site scores?
Run our free website audit. Simple report, about 10 seconds, no sign-up.



