The best questions to ask a bookkeeper before hiring are about how the work actually gets done: who does it, by which business day your books are closed each month, which software they run in production, what you get back if you leave, and how the fee changes as you grow. Push for specific answers (names, dates, written terms) and one call will tell you more than any proposal deck.
We put the same five questions to ourselves before we take on bookkeeping work. Below we go through each one, with what a good answer and a weak one sound like. We also cover what a bookkeeper does for a small business, what to ask if you're interviewing for an in-house role, and whether you need a bookkeeper at all if you already use QuickBooks.
What does a bookkeeper actually do for a small business?
A bookkeeper records and reconciles your financial activity so the numbers are right every month. In practice that means categorizing bank and card transactions, reconciling every account against its statement, entering bills and invoices, keeping the chart of accounts consistent, and closing the month so you get a profit and loss statement and a balance sheet you can trust.
Some bookkeepers also run bill pay, payroll or sales tax filings. Most don't prepare tax returns, run audits or give financial strategy; that's the accountant's or CPA's job. It's worth being clear on that boundary before you start asking questions, because a lot of friction in bookkeeping engagements comes from each side assuming the other one owned a task.
Bookkeeping is easy to sell and hard to buy well. Proposals look alike, and the usual discovery call spends its time on software logos and onboarding timelines rather than the things that decide whether your books close on time in month six. You don't need a long RFP. You need five questions and the patience to insist on specific answers.
What questions should you ask a bookkeeper before hiring?
These apply whether you're talking to a freelance bookkeeper, a firm or an outsourced team. We've put them in the order of how often a weak answer causes trouble later.
1. Who actually does the work?
Bookkeeping providers tend to come in three shapes: a domestic team, an offshore team behind a single account manager, or a hybrid where a named lead in your time zone reviews the work of specialists elsewhere. None of these is wrong in itself. The structure has to fit the job. A startup with a couple of transactions a day doesn't need a senior accountant touching every entry. A multi-entity business with intercompany allocations shouldn't be run by people you've never met, with nobody named as the reviewer.
A good answer sounds like this: "Here's your team. This is the lead, who works in your time zone and closes your books. These two handle categorization and reconciliation. You'll meet all three on the kickoff call."
Be wary of "you'll have a dedicated account manager" and nothing more. That often means one friendly contact in front of staff who rotate and whom you'll never speak to. Ask who categorizes your transactions and who reviews the close. Ask for names.
2. By which business day will our books be closed each month?
Every provider says it closes monthly. What you need to know is when, how, and what happens when it slips. A close by the fifth business day needs daily transaction capture, bank feeds and agreed cutoffs for vendor bills. A close by the fifteenth usually means the work is batched up at month-end. Both can be fine. They're different products, though, and you should know which one you're buying.
If a provider can't tell you the exact business day you'll get your financials, they aren't running a process. They're running a queue.
Then ask what happens when they miss it. A proper answer names an escalation path and a remedy written into the agreement, not an apology email. For reference, our accounting team closes the books for a 12-location healthcare group in five business days every month. Before we started, the same close took fourteen.
3. Which accounting software do you run in production?
Most providers have favorite platforms. The trouble starts when a preference turns into a requirement and you only find out about the migration after signing. So don't ask which systems they "know" or are certified in. Ask which ones they close books in every month for current clients, and whether any of those clients use your exact combination of accounting system, bill pay, expense cards and payroll.
A capable provider can work in the common systems (QuickBooks Online, Xero, Sage Intacct, NetSuite) and the apps around them. A good one will also tell you plainly when your setup is the problem, and will put any migration in a written proposal you approve before the recurring work begins.
Watch out for "we have our own platform that sits on top of your accounting system." Sometimes that's harmless. Often it means your chart of accounts and your history end up living somewhere you don't control.
4. What do we get back if we leave?
Ask this on the first call and notice how quickly the answer comes. Providers that keep clients by doing good work answer straight away: a clean general ledger in an accounting system your company owns, a documented chart of accounts, every bank and card account reconciled through the last closed month, up-to-date vendor and customer lists, the supporting documents, and the procedures the team followed. They'll talk you through a handover plan and won't charge you to export your own data.
Providers that keep clients through friction hedge. You'll hear about offboarding fees, a chart of accounts "customized for our platform", or documents kept in a portal you lose access to soon after you cancel. Even if you never plan to leave, we think this is the most revealing question on the list. A clear answer tells you a lot about how the relationship will feel when something goes wrong.
5. How will the fee change as we grow?
Buyers tend to focus on the starting fee. The surprise usually comes at renewal, when transaction volume has doubled and the bill has gone up on per-transaction terms nobody read closely. There are three honest ways to structure bookkeeping fees, and it helps to know which one you're being offered:
| Fee model | How it works | What to ask |
|---|---|---|
| Flat monthly fee with volume bands | One fee covers a defined range of transactions and accounts | What is the band, and what triggers a re-quote? |
| Per transaction or per account | The fee scales with your volume | How exactly are transactions counted, and where is that written down? |
| Base fee plus usage | A flat fee covers the close and review; high-volume tasks such as bill processing are charged by volume | Which tasks sit outside the base fee? |
Also ask what counts as out of scope, how out-of-scope work is billed, and how often a typical client ends up paying for it. A fixed fee that quietly turns into hourly billing for "extras" isn't really fixed. For the factors that drive the fee in the first place, see our guide What affects the cost of outsourced bookkeeping? A US guide.
What should you ask a bookkeeper in an interview?
If you're hiring a bookkeeper onto your own payroll rather than using a firm, the five questions above still apply in spirit, but the conversation gets more hands-on. These are the questions we'd ask:
- Walk me through how you reconcile a bank account that's out by a small amount. Where do you look first?
- Which accounting systems have you closed books in, and roughly how many transactions a month?
- Tell me about a month-end close that went wrong. What happened, and what did you change afterwards?
- What do you do when a receipt or invoice is missing?
- What would you need from me in your first two weeks?
- Which tasks would you expect our outside accountant or CPA to handle?
A short practical test tells you more than any answer. Give the candidate a bank statement and a matching ledger export with two or three planted errors, and see what they find in twenty minutes. Plan for cover too. An in-house bookkeeper takes holidays, gets sick and sometimes leaves, and your close shouldn't stop when they do. Our post Outsource accounting vs hire in-house: six honest variables goes through that trade-off in more depth.
Do you need a bookkeeper or an accountant?
Usually both, for different jobs. A bookkeeper keeps the records accurate every month. An accountant or CPA works from those records to prepare tax returns and year-end accounts and to advise on structure and planning. If the books are wrong, the accountant has to fix them before doing the work you hired them for, or files from bad numbers.
Very small businesses sometimes have their accountant do everything once a year. That works until you need monthly numbers for a lender, an investor or your own decisions. Once you're asking "how did last month go?" and nobody can tell you until tax season, you need bookkeeping.
Do you need a bookkeeper if you have QuickBooks?
QuickBooks, Xero and similar tools automate a lot of the data entry. Bank feeds pull in transactions, rules suggest categories, and receipts can be matched from your phone. What the software doesn't do is check whether its suggestions are right. Rules misfire, transfers between your own accounts get booked as income, and one payment covering two invoices confuses the matching.
If you have a few dozen transactions a month and someone on the team who doesn't mind the work, software alone can be enough. Once volume grows, or you add payroll, inventory, a second entity or accrual accounting, someone needs to review and reconcile the books every month. That's the bookkeeper's job, whether they sit in your office or on an outsourced team. If you're already months behind, read our guide to catch-up bookkeeping before you hire anyone for the ongoing work.
A checklist to take into the next call
BOOKKEEPER SCREENING CHECKLIST
[ ] Team members named, with roles and locations
[ ] Lead in your time zone identified by name
[ ] Close date stated in business days (e.g. "BD+5")
[ ] Written close commitment with escalation path and remedy
[ ] Accounting systems used in production listed (not certifications)
[ ] Migration policy: no change to your stack without written approval
[ ] Offboarding: clean GL export, documented chart of accounts, no exit fee
[ ] Documentation handover confirmed in writing
[ ] Fee model named: flat / per unit / base plus usage
[ ] Volume band defined, with what triggers a re-quote
[ ] Out-of-scope work and how it's billed explained in writing
[ ] Reference call with a client on a similar setupIf a provider can't give clear answers to at least four of the five questions, keep looking.
What good looks like in practice
First, a hypothetical example of how a weak setup shows itself. A founder signs with a firm that promised a close by the fifth business day. By month three the close lands on day eighteen, the named manager has changed twice, and the chart of accounts lives in the firm's own portal. Leaving means a migration and a cleanup project. Each of those problems would have shown up in the answers to questions one to four.
Now a real one. A private healthcare group with 12 clinics in the UK and Ireland came to us with its bookkeeping split across four different systems and a spreadsheet, a 14-day manual close, and seven audit adjustments at year-end. Our accounting team agreed a single chart of accounts with the CFO and the external auditor, moved all 12 sites into one Xero instance over 14 weeks, and handed daily processing to a team with a senior accountant owning the close. Month-end now closes in five business days, and audit adjustments went from seven to zero. The full story is in our case study Healthcare practice scaled bookkeeping across 12 locations.
Honestly, the best bookkeeping is the kind you stop noticing. If you're thinking about your bookkeeper more than once a week, one of those five answers probably went wrong. If you'd like to put these questions to us, our outsourced bookkeeping team will answer them in writing.
Frequently asked questions
What questions should I ask when hiring a bookkeeper?
Ask who does the work and who reviews it, by which business day your books will be closed, which accounting software they use in production, what you get back if you leave, and how the fee changes as your volume grows. Push for names, dates and written terms.
What does a bookkeeper do for a small business?
A bookkeeper categorizes transactions, reconciles bank and card accounts, records bills and invoices, and closes each month so you have an accurate profit and loss statement and balance sheet. Some also handle bill pay, payroll or sales tax.
How do I find a good bookkeeper?
Ask for a reference from a client of a similar size on similar software, run through the five questions in this article, and give your finalists a small practical task. A good bookkeeper answers specifically and asks you useful questions back about your accounts and deadlines.
Do I need a bookkeeper or a CPA?
Most growing businesses need both. The bookkeeper keeps the records right every month, and the CPA uses them for tax returns, year-end work and advice.
What are the red flags when hiring a bookkeeper?
No named reviewer, no committed close date, a proprietary platform that holds your data, fees to export your own records, and vague answers about what counts as out of scope.
See it in practice · Healthcare
Healthcare practice scaled bookkeeping across 12 locations
Curious how your own site scores?
Run our free website audit. Simple report, about 10 seconds, no sign-up.



